1993
1994
- Arnold Skaaland
- Bobo Brazil
- Buddy Rogers
- Chief Jay Strongbow
- Freddie Blassie
- Gorilla Monsoon
- James Dudley
1995
- Antonino Rocca
- Ernie Ladd
- The Fabulous Moolah
- George Steele
- The Grand Wizard
- Ivan Putski
- Pedro Morales
1996
- Baron Mikel Scicluna
- Jimmy Snuka
- Johnny Rodz
- Killer Kowalski
- Lou Albano
- Pat Patterson
- Vincent J. McMahon
- The Valiant Brothers - Jimmy Valiant & Johnny Valiant
2004
- Billy Graham
- Bobby Heenan
- Don Muraco
- Greg Valentine
- Harley Race
- Jesse Ventura
- John Studd
- The Junkyard Dog
- Sergeant Slaughter
- Tito Santana
- Pete Rose (Celebrity Wing)
2005
- Bob Orton Jr.
- Hulk Hogan
- The Iron Sheik
- Jimmy Hart
- Nikolai Volkoff
- Paul Orndorff
- Roddy Piper
2006
- Bret Hart
- Eddie Guerrero
- Gene Okerlund
- Sensational Sherri
- Tony Atlas
- Verne Gagne
- The Blackjacks - Blackjack Lanza & Blackjack Mulligan
- William Perry (Celebrity Wing)
2007
- Dusty Rhodes
- Jerry Lawler
- Jim Ross
- Mr. Fuji
- Mr. Perfect
- Nick Bockwinkel
- The Sheik
- The Wild Samoans - Afa & Sika
2008
- Eddie Graham
- Gordon Solie
- Mae Young
- Peter Maivia
- Ric Flair
- Rocky Johnson
- The Brisco Brothers - Jack Brisco & Gerald Brisco
2009
- Bill Watts
- Howard Finkel
- Koko B. Ware
- Ricky Steamboat
- Steve Austin
- The Funks - Dory Funk Jr. & Terry Funk
- The Von Erich Family - Chris, David, Fritz, Kerry, Kevin, & Mike Von Erich
2010
- Antonio Inoki
- Gorgeous George
- Mad Dog Vachon
- Stu Hart
- Ted DiBiase
- Wendi Richter
- Bob Uecker (Celebrity Wing)
2011
- Abdullah the Butcher
- Bob Armstrong
- Jim Duggan
- Shawn Michaels
- Sunny
- The Road Warriors - Animal & Hawk with Paul Ellering
- Drew Carey (Celebrity Wing)
2012
- Edge
- Mil Mascaras
- Ron Simmons
- Yokozuna
- The Four Horsemen - Arn Anderson, Barry Windham, JJ Dillon, Ric Flair, & Tully Blanchard
- Mike Tyson (Celebrity Wing)
2013
- Bob Backlund
- Booker T
- Bruno Sammartino
- Mick Foley
- Trish Stratus
- Donald Trump (Celebrity Wing)
2014
- Carlos Colon
- Jake Roberts
- Lita
- Paul Bearer
- Razor Ramon
- The Ultimate Warrior
- Mr. T (Celebrity Wing)
2015
- Alundra Blayze
- Kevin Nash
- Larry Zbyszko
- Randy Savage
- Rikishi
- Tatsumi Fujinami
- The Bushwackers - Butch Miller & Luke Williams
- Arnold Schwarzenegger (Celebrity Wing)
- Connor "The Crusher" Michalek (Warrior Award)
2016
- Art Thomas
- The Big Bossman
- Ed Lewis
- Frank Gotch
- George Hackenschmidt
- The Godfather
- Jacqueline
- Lou Thesz
- Mildred Burke
- Pat O'Connor
- Stan Hansen
- Sting
- The Fabulous Freebirds - Buddy Roberts, Jimmy Garvin, Michael Hayes, & Terry Gordy
- Snoop Dogg (Celebrity Wing)
- Joan Lunden (Warrior Award)
2017
- Bearcat Wright
- Beth Phoenix
- Dallas Page
- Haystacks Calhoun
- Jerry Graham
- Judy Grable
- June Byers
- Kurt Angle
- Luther Lindsay
- Martin Burns
- Rick Rude
- Rikidozan
- Teddy Long
- Toots Mondt
- The Rock n' Roll Express - Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson
- Eric LeGrand (Warrior Award)
2018
- Bill Goldberg
- Boris Malenko
- Cora Combs
- Dara Singh
- El Santo
- Hillbilly Jim
- Hiro Matsuda
- Ivory
- Jeff Jarrett
- Jim Londos
- Lord Alfred Hayes
- Mark Henry
- Rufus R. Jones
- Sputnik Monroe
- Stan Stasiak
- The Dudley Boyz - Bubba Ray Dudley & D-Von Dudley
- Kid Rock (Celebrity Wing)
- Jarrius "JJ" Robertson (Warrior Award)
2019
- Bruiser Brody
- Brutus Beefcake
- Buddy Rose
- Hisashi Shinma
- The Honky Tonk Man
- Jim Barnett
- Joseph Cohen
- Luna Vachon
- Primo Carnera
- SD Jones
- Torrie Wilson
- Toru Tanaka
- Wahoo McDaniel
- D-Generation X - Billy Gunn, Chyna, Jesse James, Shawn Michaels, Triple H, & X-Pac
- Harlem Heat - Booker T & Stevie Ray
- The Hart Foundation - Bret Hart & Jim Neidhart
- Sue Aitchison (Warrior Award)
2020
- Baron Michele Leone
- Brickhouse Brown
- Davey Boy Smith
- Gary Hart
- John Bradshaw Layfield
- Jushin Liger
- Ray Stevens
- Steve Williams
- The Bella Twins - Brie Bella & Nikki Bella
- The New World Order (nWo) - Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, & Sean Waltman
- William Shatner (Celebrity Wing)
- Titus O'Neil (Warrior Award)
2021
- Buzz Sawyer
- Dick the Bruiser
- Eric Bischoff
- Ethel Johnson
- Kane
- The Great Khali
- Molly Holly
- Paul Boesch
- Pez Whatley
- Rob Van Dam
- Ozzy Osbourne (Celebrity Wing)
- Rich Hering (Warrior Award)
2022
- Queen Sharmell
- The Undertaker
- Vader
- The Steiner Brothers - Rick Steiner & Scott Steiner
- Shad Gaspard (Warrior Award)
2023
- The Great Muta
- Rey Mysterio
- Stacy Keibler
- Andy Kaufman (Celebrity Wing)
- Tim White (Warrior Award)
2024
- Bull Nakano
- Lia Maivia
- Paul Heyman
- Thunderbolt Patterson
- The U.S. Express - Barry Windham & Mike Rotunda
- Muhammad Ali (Celebrity Wing)
