COMEBACK OF THE YEAR
2023
Trinity
1. Saraya
2. Adam Cole
3. Trish Stratus
2022
Taya Valkyrie
1. Bayley
2. Johnny Gargano
3. Alexa Bliss
2021
CM Punk
1. Sting
2. Christian Cage
3. Becky Lynch
2020
Montel Vontavious Porter
1. Randy Orton
2. Eric Young
3. Asuka
2019
Roman Reigns
1. Bray Wyatt
2. Dustin Rhodes
3. Sasha Banks
2018
Daniel Bryan
1. Drew McIntyre
2. PCO
3. Shawn Michaels
2017
The Hardy Boyz (Jeff Hardy (3) & Matt Hardy)
1. Finn Balor
2. Mickie James
3. Shelton Benjamin
2016
Bill Goldberg
1. Seth Rollins
2. Chris Jericho
3. Matt Hardy
2015
The Undertaker
1. Sheamus
2. Roderick Strong
3. Daniel Bryan
2014
Sting (3)
1. Bobby Lashley
2. Dave Batista
3. The New Age Outlaws
2013
Goldust
1. Chris Sabin
2. Jerry Lawler
3. The Bella Twins
2012
Jeff Hardy (2)
1. The Rock
2. Brock Lesnar
3. Layla
2011
Sting (2)
1. Mark Henry
2. Austin Aries
3. Montel Vontavious Porter
2010
Rob Van Dam (2)
1. Kane
2. Edge
3. Jeff Hardy
2009
Jerry Lynn
1. Ricky Steamboat
2. The Undertaker
3. Mick Foley
2008
Chris Jericho
1. Jeff Jarrett
2. William Regal
3. Sheik Abdul Bashir
2007
Jeff Hardy
1. Triple H
2. Rey Mysterio
3. The Steiner Brothers
2006
Sting
1. Sabu
2. Jeff Hardy
3. Fit Finlay
2005
Animal
1. Matt Hardy
2. Raven
3. Hulk Hogan
2004
Edge
1. Jeff Hardy
2. William Regal
3. Chavo Guerrero
2003
Kurt Angle
1. Bill Goldberg
2. Raven
3. The Ultimo Dragon
2002
Hulk Hogan (2)
1. Eddie Guerrero
2. Chris Benoit
3. Ron Killings
2001
Rob Van Dam
1. Steve Austin
2. Booker T
3. Scott Hall
2000
Rikishi
1. Dusty Rhodes
2. The Undertaker
3. Vince McMahon
1999
Eddie Guerrero
1. Buff Bagwell
2. Curt Hennig
3. Michael Hayes
1998
X-Pac
1. Sting
2. Dean Malenko
3. The Warrior
1997
Bret Hart
1. Curt Hennig
2. Brian Pillman
3. Ric Flair
1996
Sycho Sid
1. Jake Roberts
2. Faarooq
3. Animal
1995
Randy Savage
1. The Heavenly Bodies
2. Savio Vega
3. The Ultimate Warrior
1994
Hulk Hogan
1. Bob Backlund
2. The Undertaker
3. Alundra Blayze
1993
Lex Luger
1. Brutus Beefcake
2. Ric Flair
3. Paul Roma
1992
The Ultimate Warrior
1. Bob Backlund
2. The Sheik
3. The Junkyard Dog